Show shovel product reviews and compare Leave a comment
Product Reviews Summary
1. Snow Joe SJ-SHLV01 18-Inch Shovelution Strain-Reducing Snow Shovel
Pros:
- Ergonomic design with a spring-assisted handle reduces back strain and effort, making it easier to shovel snow.
- Lightweight and robust, with an 18-inch wide shovel blade and a heavy-duty aluminum wear strip.
- The dual-handle system is effective in leveraging the powerful muscles of the upper body, reducing the effort required for shoveling.
- Positive feedback from users in their fifties and above, appreciating the reduced back pain and ease of use.
- Generally good for lifting and first-pass clearing of snow.
Cons:
- Some users reported durability concerns, particularly with the lower handle.
- The shovel’s angle and wear strip might not be suitable for close scraping.
- Not ideal for very tall individuals.
- A few users experienced issues with the metal strip on the shovel breaking off.
Overall: This shovel is well-received for its ergonomic design and effectiveness in reducing back strain. It’s particularly beneficial for older users or those with back issues. However, there are some concerns about its durability and suitability for heavy-duty tasks.
2. COFIT 43″ Retractable Snow Shovel
Pros:
- Compact and lightweight, making it easy to store and transport.
- Adjustable length up to 43 inches, catering to different heights and reducing the need to bend over.
- Sturdy aluminum alloy construction, capable of withstanding significant weight.
- Comes with a carrying bag for convenience.
- Ideal for emergency situations, particularly in vehicles.
Cons:
- Not suitable for heavy-duty or rigorous use.
- Some users reported issues with the shaft being slightly loose when fully built.
- The paint coating on the scoop may strip off after several uses.
- The aluminum shaft can be cold to touch in winter, requiring gloves or additional grip tape.
Overall: This shovel is highly praised for its portability and adjustability, making it a great emergency tool for vehicles. However, it may not be the best choice for regular, heavy-duty use.
3. Garant Yukon YPP26EAKDN 26-Inch Ergonomic Snow Shovel
Pros:
- Large 26-inch poly blade is effective for scraping snow from large areas.
- The nylon strip adds durability and is safe for all surfaces.
- Ergonomic, lightweight aluminum handle improves posture and comfort during use.
- Suitable for intense and continuous use.
- Made in Canada with a mix of domestic and imported parts.
Cons:
- Some users found the shovel not heavy-duty enough for certain tasks.
- Issues with the quality of materials used, particularly the plastic clip retaining the blade.
- Not ideal for heavy snowfalls or pushing through ice and hard snow ruts.
Overall: This shovel is appreciated for its large blade and ergonomic design, making it suitable for clearing large areas of snow. However, it may not be the best choice for heavy-duty tasks or in situations with compacted snow and ice.
Comparing the three products
| Feature/Aspect | Snow Joe SJ-SHLV01 | COFIT 43″ Retractable Snow Shovel | Garant Yukon YPP26EAKDN |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blade Size | 18 inches wide | 8.3″ x 11″ | 26 inches wide |
| Handle Type | Ergonomic D-ring handle, Spring-assisted | Ergonomic T-shaped handle | Curved aluminum handle with Poly D-grip |
| Material | Aluminum wear strip | Premium Aluminum Alloy | Poly blade with nylon strip |
| Weight | 1.7 kg | 1.63 lbs / 740g | 1.7 kg |
| Length/Height | Standard, non-adjustable | Adjustable from 21″ to 43″ | Standard, non-adjustable |
| Special Features | Spring-assist handle reduces strain, suitable for lifting and throwing snow | Detachable, portable, comes with a storage bag, suitable for different user heights | Extra-large blade for scraping snow from large areas, wear-resistant nylon strip |
| Ideal Use | Heavy lifting and throwing, reducing back strain | Emergency use, particularly for vehicles | Clearing large areas, continuous use |
| Durability and Construction | Sturdy but concerns about the longevity of the secondary handle | Sturdy but not for heavy-duty use, better for emergency situations | Questions about durability due to plastic clip and thinner blade |
| Customer Satisfaction | Generally positive, praised for reducing strain, some concerns about durability | Highly valued for its portability and adjustability, not for heavy-duty use | Good for light snow, concerns about heavy-duty use |
| Price Point | Mid-range | Affordable | Good for those with back issues, but not ideal for very tall individuals |
| Additional Comments | Good for those with back issues, not ideal for very tall individuals | Excellent for keeping in vehicles for emergencies, not for regular heavy use | Great for light snowfall on smooth surfaces, not ideal for heavy or icy conditions |
Summary:
- Snow Joe SJ-SHLV01: Best for those who need a shovel that reduces back strain, suitable for regular use in lifting and throwing snow. However, there are some concerns about its durability.
- COFIT 43″ Retractable Snow Shovel: Ideal for emergency situations, especially for vehicle owners. It’s lightweight and adjustable but not meant for heavy-duty or regular use.
- Garant Yukon YPP26EAKDN: Good for clearing large areas with light snow. It has a large blade but may not be the best choice for heavy-duty or rough surface use due to durability concerns.
